what problem had more intellectual energy dedicated to it in the 20th century?

personal thoughts 

i think capitalism but the problem is significantly more complicated and the people involved were significantly less coordinated and so it largely washed out

personal thoughts 

@mutual_ayyde Why do you think capitalism? I was just looking at heat management for one of the rovers yesterday and it's much more advanced than I would have imagined and that's just a tiny thing.

personal thoughts 

@apodoxus the number of ostensible marxists counted in the millions over the course of the century alone

personal thoughts 

@mutual_ayyde @apodoxus if you want to count every ostensible Marxist as contributing intellectual energy....the entire US education was overhauled from the ground up to support the space program, so you also need to count every single HS calculus student since Sputnik.

personal thoughts 

@elfprince13 @mutual_ayyde This is an interesting point... Many who were educated to work on space-related stuff never actually got to work specifically at NASA. They ended up in Silicon Valley and Defense contracting and other stuff. Then there were the large masses which failed out of attempts at it (which there must be some equivalent in the masses of Marxists too.)

Counterpoint though: How big is the US educated population compared to the number of Marxists globally?

personal thoughts 

@apodoxus @mutual_ayyde ~64.6M HS graduates from 1959-2000, if I'm reading nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d1 (and using Excel) correctly.

Anyway, the mean, median, and modal contributions are all likely to be very low, but that's true for both populations.

personal thoughts 

@apodoxus @mutual_ayyde Also, in terms of actual progress - Marxists still don't have an answer to the knowledge and calculation problems, and in some sense this is definitional - anyone who is still a Marxist is likely not taking ECP seriously, and can't really be considered to be contributing intellectual energy.

Follow

personal thoughts 

@apodoxus @mutual_ayyde Those who took it seriously and contributed intellectual energy are now most likely some flavor of LWMA, and that's a population that I would guess is much much smaller than the number of scientists who have made productive contributions to the US space program.

· · Web · 0 · 0 · 0
Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

General topic personal server.